The Single-Subject Versus Group “Debate”
50 questions available
Questions
What is a primary concern that advocates of group research raise about the use of visual inspection in single-subject research?
View answer and explanationHow do single-subject researchers typically respond to the criticism that focusing on group means in traditional experiments can be misleading?
View answer and explanationAccording to advocates of group research, what is the primary difficulty concerning external validity in single-subject studies?
View answer and explanationHow do single-subject researchers defend the external validity of their findings against the criticism of using small samples?
View answer and explanationFor which of the following research goals would group research be considered more appropriate than single-subject research?
View answer and explanationWhat does the Principle of Converging Evidence suggest that scientists should do?
View answer and explanationIn the context of the Principle of Converging Evidence, when would confidence in a particular conclusion be undermined?
View answer and explanationAccording to single-subject researchers, what concern arises from group researchers generalizing findings from a single situation, such as a closed driving track?
View answer and explanationFor which of these research questions would group research be necessary and the single-subject approach not be applicable?
View answer and explanationWhat is the role of a 'steady state strategy' in single-subject research, according to the text?
View answer and explanationHow do group researchers address the concern that their focus on group statistics might hide individual differences?
View answer and explanationWhat point do single-subject researchers make about the external validity of group research findings when applied to a single new individual?
View answer and explanationSingle-subject research is described as being particularly good for testing the effectiveness of treatments under what condition?
View answer and explanationWhat is the key takeaway from 'The Principle of Converging Evidence' regarding the quest for a 'perfect' experiment?
View answer and explanationWhat is the typical trade-off between true experiments and non-experimental research mentioned in the context of the Principle of Converging Evidence?
View answer and explanationWhat role can factorial designs play in addressing the concerns raised in the single-subject versus group research debate?
View answer and explanationWhen single-subject researchers find an effect that is difficult to detect through visual inspection due to noisy data, what is their likely course of action?
View answer and explanationWhat example is provided in the text to show how research from both single-subject and group traditions can be successfully integrated?
View answer and explanationWhat is meant by the statement that the single-subject and group approaches represent different 'research traditions'?
View answer and explanationWhy is group research considered more efficient than single-subject research for studying interactions between treatments and participant characteristics?
View answer and explanationWhat is one of the three specific concerns advocates of group research have regarding visual inspection of data in single-subject studies?
View answer and explanationIf a treatment in a group study positively affects half the participants and negatively affects the other half, what is the likely outcome when looking at the group mean?
View answer and explanationWhat is the single-subject researchers' view on the generalization of principles like classical and operant conditioning?
View answer and explanationAccording to the Principle of Converging Evidence, when can researchers have increased confidence in their conclusions, even when individual studies are flawed?
View answer and explanationWhat is the primary reason that a clinician working with a single client might choose a single-subject research design?
View answer and explanationWhat is the main point of the 'Data Analysis' section in the debate between single-subject and group researchers?
View answer and explanationIn the debate on external validity, what is the core issue that both single-subject and group researchers are ultimately concerned with?
View answer and explanationWhat does the text suggest is probably the best way to conceptualize single-subject and group research?
View answer and explanationWhat does the text conclude about scientific proof based on the Principle of Converging Evidence?
View answer and explanationWhen single-subject researchers are criticized for the unreliability of visual inspection, how do they defend their method?
View answer and explanationA study finds a treatment reduces self-injury in two children with intellectual disabilities. What is the external validity concern a group researcher would raise?
View answer and explanationIn the final paragraph of Chapter 46, the text states, 'In science, we strive for progress, not perfection.' What does this mean in the context of the chapter?
View answer and explanationWhat is the primary benefit of using a within-subjects design in group research, in the context of the debate with single-subject researchers?
View answer and explanationWhat is the key takeaway regarding the generalization of results based on the number of participants studied?
View answer and explanationIf a single-subject researcher, after trying to strengthen an effect and reduce data noise, still finds the effect difficult to detect, what is the likely conclusion?
View answer and explanationWhat is the primary reason group research is considered ideal for testing the effectiveness of treatments at the group level?
View answer and explanationIn the context of the data analysis debate, what is the significance of a bimodal distribution of scores in a treatment group?
View answer and explanationWhy do single-subject researchers argue that statistical analysis is becoming a more common supplement to visual inspection?
View answer and explanationThe text argues that the Principle of Converging Evidence allows science to overcome the fact that 'no design is perfect.' How does it do this?
View answer and explanationWhat is the fundamental difference in approach to external validity between single-subject and group researchers?
View answer and explanationIf a group study shows a small positive effect on average for a treatment, what is the concern a single-subject researcher might have?
View answer and explanationWhat is the role of 'research traditions' in the ongoing use of both single-subject and group research approaches?
View answer and explanationAccording to the text, why can a research finding based on a collection of studies with different flaws be more convincing than a finding based on a collection of studies with similar flaws?
View answer and explanationOne concern about visual inspection is that it is 'unreliable'. What does this mean in the context of data analysis?
View answer and explanationWhich statement best summarizes the resolution proposed in the chapter to the 'debate' between single-subject and group research?
View answer and explanationWhat is the primary strength of a true experiment that a non-experimental (correlational) study typically lacks?
View answer and explanationA key point made by single-subject researchers is that focusing on group means can be 'highly misleading.' Why is this the case?
View answer and explanationAccording to the chapter, what is the value in detecting a 'weak effect' through group research?
View answer and explanationIf you wanted to study the relationship between a personality trait like extraversion and the number of friends a person has, why would a group design be more appropriate than a single-subject design?
View answer and explanationWhat is the final message of the chapter regarding the search for truth in psychology?
View answer and explanation